Teen Mom's Catelynn & Tyler: Carly's Adoption Drama & Closed Contact
Can the bonds of family truly transcend the complexities of adoption, or are some relationships destined to be severed by circumstance? The ongoing saga of Catelynn Lowell and Tyler Baltierra, stars of MTV's "Teen Mom," and their daughter Carly's adoptive parents, Brandon and Teresa Davis, offers a poignant exploration of this question, revealing the emotional intricacies that can arise when open adoption agreements are challenged.
Open adoption, in its ideal form, is a bridge between birth parents and adoptive parents, designed to facilitate ongoing contact and information sharing about the child. Tyler and Catelynn initially embraced this arrangement with Carlys adoptive parents, hoping to maintain a connection with the daughter they placed for adoption in 2009. Their journey, documented for years on reality television, has become a powerful lens through which to examine the realities of adoption, showcasing both the triumphs and the heartbreaking setbacks that can occur. However, what happens when the agreed-upon terms of that relationship are broken?
The narrative of Catelynn and Tyler's journey began in 2009 when, as teenagers, they welcomed Carly, their first child. The couple, catapulted into the spotlight on MTV's "16 & Pregnant," made the difficult but loving decision to place Carly for adoption, choosing Brandon and Teresa Davis as her adoptive parents. The agreement at the time was for an open adoption, allowing the Baltierras to see Carly regularly. For a time, the arrangement seemed to work well. Catelynn and Tyler were able to see Carly annually, maintaining a connection that, while perhaps bittersweet, offered comfort and hope.
| Subject | Details |
|---|---|
| Name | Catelynn Lowell Baltierra |
| Date of Birth | March 12, 1992 |
| Age | 32 (as of October 26, 2024) |
| Marital Status | Married to Tyler Baltierra |
| Children | Carly (adopted), Nova, Vaeda, Rya |
| Occupation | Reality Television Personality, Entrepreneur |
| Known For | MTV's "16 & Pregnant," "Teen Mom" |
| Social Media | |
| Adoption Journey | Placed her first child, Carly, for adoption in 2009. |
The shift in their relationship with Brandon and Teresa Davis seems to have been gradual, marked by a series of events that ultimately led to a painful severing of communication. Catelynn has been vocal about the change, expressing her frustration and sadness on social media and during interviews. The specifics of the disagreements remain somewhat private, but the central issue seems to be a change in the Davises' stance on the level of contact they were comfortable with, eventually leading to them blocking the Baltierras from all communication with Carly. This action left Catelynn heartbroken and feeling shut out of her daughter's life.
In 2009, when Carly was adopted, the agreement was to maintain an open relationship. This meant regular contact, photos, and updates. The Baltierras dutifully shared updates and pictures, seeking to remain involved in Carly's life and the lives of her adoptive parents. Catelynn has spoken of the pain of not being able to share in her daughter's life moments. The initial years saw them visiting Carly annually, creating a sense of hope and continuity. These visits, however, were not to last. As Carly grew older, the dynamics shifted. Brandon and Teresa Davis, for reasons they haven't publicly specified, changed their approach. They stopped providing any information, and ultimately, blocked Catelynn and Tyler on social media.
The "Teen Mom" stars have become increasingly outspoken about the situation. Catelynn, in particular, has shared her anguish and disappointment with her fans, turning to social media and other platforms to express her feelings. Shes openly criticized the Davises for what she perceives as a breach of the initial adoption agreement. One instance of this was when Catelynn called out Brandon and Teresa Davis on her Instagram story, claiming that the couple, who adopted Carly from Catelynn and her husband Tyler Baltierra in 2009, had blocked them. Catelynn, in a display of raw emotion, shared photos of her younger daughters, Nova, Vaeda, and Rya, intending to keep Carly in the loop, despite the contact ban.
The situation has brought into question the realities of open adoption and the power dynamics inherent in such arrangements. While open adoption is designed to benefit all parties involved, it also requires a significant degree of cooperation and a shared understanding of expectations. When those expectations shift, the potential for conflict and emotional distress is significant. The Baltierras experiences highlight the vulnerability of birth parents, who often have little legal recourse when adoptive parents choose to limit contact.
Tyler, too, has addressed the issue publicly. He has used his platform to discuss the situation and, like Catelynn, has expressed his deep sadness and frustration at the loss of contact with Carly. He has emphasized the importance of maintaining bonds and the pain of having those bonds severed without clear explanation. Both Catelynn and Tyler have been very outspoken about the injustices of adoption in general, as well as their unhappiness with Carlys parents, Brandon and Teresa Davis, for closing the adoption and cutting off contact between them and Carly last year.
The ongoing saga of Catelynn, Tyler, and Carly's adoptive parents continues to unfold on the "Teen Mom" franchise. The new season promises to delve further into the challenges they face and their efforts to navigate the complexities of their relationships. The show will also cover the journey the couple took with their three younger daughters, Nova, Vaeda, and Rya. The family still grapples with the effects of a closed adoption and the emotions it stirred. Both Catelynn and Tyler remain hopeful about the future and dedicated to their children. Catelynn and Tyler baltierra, both of whom were 17 when they welcomed biological daughter Carly in 2009, have long feuded with her adoptive parents.
The events that transpired underscore the need for open communication, clear expectations, and a willingness to adapt as children grow and family dynamics evolve. When the foundational principles of an open adoption are compromised, the consequences can be devastating, especially for the birth parents who are left to grapple with the loss of the connection they once shared.
Catelynn and Tyler's story also highlights a lack of control that birth parents have after the adoption is complete. They were first introduced to teen mom fans when they starred on 16 & pregnant and expecting their first daughter, carly, way back in 2009. The ability of adoptive parents to unilaterally close off contact, even when an open adoption agreement has been established, leaves birth parents feeling helpless and heartbroken. This power imbalance can lead to feelings of injustice and frustration, as the birth parents are left with little recourse to maintain the relationship with their child.
In January 2025, Catelynn shared, in an interview alongside her husband Tyler Baltierra, that Carlys adoptive parents, Brandon and Teresa Davis, had ceased contact with her. This statement highlighted the reality of a closed adoption and the pain that comes with it. As fans of the show know, Carly was born in 2009, and her birth and adoption were featured on Cates 16 and Pregnant episode. The "Teen Mom" star who, along with her husband Tyler Baltierra has been very outspoken about the injustices of adoption in general, as well as their unhappiness with Carlys parents, Brandon and Teresa Davis, for closing the adoption and cutting off contact between them and Carly last year.
The experience raises questions about the long-term implications of closed adoptions. While some adoptive parents may choose to limit contact for various reasons, the impact on birth parents can be profound. The loss of connection, the unanswered questions, and the sense of unresolved grief can be emotionally damaging. Cate and Tys relationship with Brandon and Teresa soured to the point of the couple cutting off communication with the Teen Mom stars all together.
For the Baltierras, this has meant navigating a complex landscape of emotions. On the one hand, they are parents of three young children. On the other, they have a deep sense of loss related to their eldest child. This duality is a challenge, and the ongoing discussion surrounding their story has made their experience relatable to many others. Catelynn and Tyler are not alone in their struggles. Many birth parents experience similar issues with the adoptive parents, as they also try to connect with their children. Sharing their story has helped to shed light on the broader issues of adoption and the ongoing needs of birth parents.
The adoption journey is further complicated by the varying interpretations of "openness." While "open adoption" ideally means an ongoing relationship with sharing of information about a child, the reality can be much more nuanced. Some adoptive parents may welcome regular contact, while others may prefer a more limited relationship, which is what the Davises ultimately chose. During her tiktok live session on wednesday, Catelynn and Tyler Baltierra spoke with adoption counselor Dawn about the pause in their relationship with their daughter Carly, whom they placed for adoption in 2009.
It is also important to note that, in the end, the adoptive parents have the legal rights and responsibilities. The birth parents rights, by law, are often limited once the adoption is finalized, which means they cannot influence decisions about the childs life. This imbalance in power creates a situation in which the adoptive parents have the autonomy to determine the level of contact. This inherent power differential can lead to tension, as birth parents navigate their desire to remain connected. Carlys adoptive parents did not give any reason before blocking contact.
The challenges are not unique to Catelynn and Tyler. Many birth parents struggle to maintain relationships with adoptive parents. Sometimes, it's because the dynamics between the families change over time. Open adoption can be a wonderful experience, but it does not guarantee ongoing and consistent contact. One bio parent wanted open adoption and it has been a wonderful experience for both families, but the bio family from the second child did not want it open. The case of Catelynn and Tyler is a reminder that open adoption requires constant communication, mutual respect, and a shared commitment to the child's well-being. The teen mom stars have become increasingly outspoken in recent months since the adoption was closed.
The narrative surrounding the Baltierras and the Davises is also a reminder of the complexities of family. The couple is still adjusting to a change in dynamics. The adoptive parents, Brandon and Teresa Davis, have been famously private regarding their eldest child. They have chosen a path that prioritizes their own privacy and the well-being of their family. While that decision has caused pain for the Baltierras, it underscores the right of adoptive parents to make decisions regarding their adopted child. The situation serves as a caution, highlighting how complex adoption can be.
The story also reveals the long-term impact of decisions made early in life. Catelynn baltierra, who was 16 when she placed biological daughter carly for adoption, has been calling out carly's adoptive parents on social media for months. The situation reveals the enduring emotional scars that adoption can leave, even years later. The fact that the situation continues to be the subject of discussion demonstrates how personal these matters are, how they continue to affect the lives of those involved, and the long-term consequences of any adoption plan. Fifteen years after teen moms catelynn lowell and tyler baltierra put their daughter carly up for adoption, they learned her adoptive parents blocked them in an exclusive look at the feb. episode of the show.
In an interview, the Baltierras were candid about the challenges of their situation. They are, after all, very public figures, and their story has been documented for years. They continue to use their platform to advocate for birth parents. They are vocal about adoption and their experiences, hoping to foster a better understanding of the realities of open adoption. Catelynn is still committed to finding a way to reconnect. While speaking to dawn baker, who facilitated carlys adoption, lowell said she will continue to try to contact carly.
The saga of Catelynn Lowell, Tyler Baltierra, and their daughter Carly's adoptive parents is a testament to the enduring power of family, the challenges of open adoption, and the resilience of the human spirit. Their story continues to unfold, reminding us of the complexities of the adoption process, the need for open communication, and the lasting impact of family bonds.
